Price Range: From to

Compare Listings

4 acre Lakefront Home on Mayhem Pond Gilboa NY

161 S Gilboa Rd, Stamford, NY 12167, USA


4 acre Lakefront 4 Bedroom Home for Sale on Mayham Pond, Gilboa, NY!

Modern Home in the Catskills, Great for Boating, Swimming and Fishing!

4.04 acres renovated lakefront farmhouse located at 61 South Gilboa Road, Gilboa, NY 12167. This is one of the rare opportunities where you can literally fish from your back deck as this home sits less than 40 feet from the edge of Mayhem Pond.  All the comforts and more as this renovated, modern farmhouse has everything you need for a vacation home on a mountain lake or primary residence in the country.

Lake House:  1,872 square feet consisting of 4 upstairs bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, laundry area, large kitchen with maple cabinetry, dishwasher and island, spacious dining room attached and wonderful living room area with picture window looking right into the water. All amenities are modern with renovated electric, plumbing, and new Anderson windows.  New fireplace in living room and brand new drilled well.  Other features include a one car garage, breezeway for cool summer evenings, and large deck in backyard for grilling, relaxing and gazing at sunsets, stars and the nearby Mayham Pond.

Land: 4.04 acres with over 1,000 feet of water frontage.  Consists of two parcels (1 and 2).  The home is on parcel 2  (approx 1 acre) and this has mowed grass right to the edge of the water.  Parcel 1 (approx. 3 acres) is vacant land (buildable) with the Catskill Scenic Trail running along its west side.

With both properties combined, it makes a wonderful, level yard for gardening, fruit trees, Christmas trees, or just an outdoor playground for family and friends.  Eagles and hawks frequent the trees along the edge of the water of parcel 2.  Both parcels have access to a common area along a peninsula in the middle of Mayhem Pond for additional pond access, picnics, hiking and family get togethers.

Mayham Pond: 

  • Approximately 40 acres (private lake).
  • Allows kayaks, canoes, trolling motor boating and is known for excellent fishing with bass, pickerel, catfish and panfish.
  • Swimming.
  • Abundant in wildlife as it is loaded with ducks, geese, beaver, mink, turtles.
  • Eagles circle the lake routinely.


  • 25 minutes to major ski resorts.
  • 10 minutes to golf.
  • 30 minutes to Oneonta.
  • 60 minutes to Albany Airport.
  • 2.5 hours to NY City.

Property is part of the Pine Island Farm Homeowners Association.

This is a one-of-a-kind waterfront home right on the shore of Mayham Pond!  Very rare opportunity!

Priced to Sell $449,900. Contact Pete Martino at 315-269-3487 for more information or to schedule a showing.  Shown by appointment only.



Property Documents

  • Address: Gilboa Rd
  • Zip/Postal Code: 12167
  • Country: United States


Updated on November 17, 2022 at 7:59 am

  • Property ID: NYOR698
  • Price: $449,900
  • Property Size: 1872 Sq Ft
  • Land Area: 4 acres
  • Bedrooms: 4
  • Bathrooms: 2
  • Garage: 1
  • Year Built: 1875
  • Property Type: Deals Pending/Sold
  • Property Status: Sold

Contact info

Pete Martino, Licensed Real Estate Broker/Owner
Pete Martino, Licensed Real Estate Broker/Owner
Facebook Twitter Linkedin

Inquire about this property